Majority vs. Truth

One of Papa's favourite quotations was:
The majority principle is not a truth principle.
He brought it up as a reminder that it is more important to investigate the right of things,
than to thoughtlessly follow where the majority leads.

Terracotta amphora (jar)
of a judge, on one side
Attic Greek, 490 B.C.
in the Metropolitan Museum of Art
via Wikimedia Commons

Often he applied this quotation to discussions of political ideas and situations, like our ideals of democracy.

But it also, I'd argue preachily, reflected his general belief that we should not calibrate conscience or thought by how others feel or act. There is an abstracter truth which we must try to grasp independently, and which should guide our life conduct.

In my favourable opinion, this approach meant that Papa had a lot of integrity. It also probably required much determination as well as moral belief to turn the theory into practice.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Papa and Haydn Cello Concertos

The Quality of Mercy is not Strained

Liebestraum and the 'Practice Pile'